Bilstein

Bilstein vs ST Coilovers for BMW M140i & M240i: Owner Reviews

BMW M140i at Goodwood, illustrating a Bilstein versus ST coilover buying guide

Which coilovers are best for the BMW M140i and M240i? We compare Bilstein B14 and B16 with ST X, XA and XTA, then look at real-world owner reports from PistonHeads, Reddit and BMW enthusiast forums. The aim is to help you choose a suspension upgrade that suits British roads and the way you actually drive.

The F20/F21 M140i and F22/F23 M240i combine the 340PS B58 straight-six with rear-wheel-drive performance. They are capable cars, but body movement and a sometimes unsettled rear end are regular topics in owner discussions. A properly chosen coilover kit can improve body control, ride height and driver confidence. It will not, however, compensate for poor tyres, worn bushes or unsuitable wheel alignment.

Bilstein vs ST coilovers: the key differences

Coilover Height adjustment Damper adjustment Best suited to
Bilstein B14 Yes Factory-set Simple fast-road upgrade
Bilstein B16 Yes 10-position coupled rebound/compression Adjustable fast-road setup
ST X Yes Factory-set Road use and lowering
ST XA Yes 16-click rebound Daily and fast-road use
ST XTA Yes Rebound; top mounts on applicable kits More focused fast-road builds
ST XTA Plus 3 Yes Separate rebound and low-/high-speed compression Advanced road/track setups

Always confirm the exact variant and equipment for your vehicle: not every product configuration applies to every M140i, M240i, xDrive or electronically damped car.

Bilstein B14: straightforward, controlled handling

The Bilstein B14 offers adjustable ride height with matched monotube gas-pressure dampers and fixed damping. Its appeal is simplicity: after fitting and setting the ride height, there are no damping controls to manage.

On the M140i, owners frequently praise the reduction in rear-end float and improved control during enthusiastic driving. The trade-off can be a firmer reaction to smaller road imperfections. If you want a largely set-and-forget suspension upgrade, B14 deserves serious consideration.

ST XA: adjustable rebound for road comfort and control

ST Suspensions forms part of KW Automotive. Its ST XA coilovers offer adjustable ride height plus 16-click rebound adjustment. Rebound adjustment changes how the suspension controls its return after compression; it is not independent compression adjustment.

That flexibility matters when an M140i or M240i is used for commuting as well as weekend driving. As the real owner reports below show, an installation that is too low or too firm for one driver can sometimes be improved through careful adjustment. ST uses galvanised steel strut housings, rather than the stainless-steel construction found on many higher-priced KW systems.

Shop ST XA coilovers for the BMW M140i and M240i.

Real BMW M140i and M240i owner reviews

The following accounts were reviewed from first-hand forum posts. They are anecdotal experiences, not controlled back-to-back testing. We have retained the important caveats where owners changed other suspension components at the same time.

Bilstein B14: owner experiences

Mr911lover (BMW M140i)

After fitting B14 coilovers and BMW M Performance rear bump stops, this owner reported that the rear end felt far more connected and that the previously floaty sensation had largely gone. They deliberately avoided excessive lowering to preserve road usability. Because the bump stops changed at the same time, the improvement cannot be attributed exclusively to the coilovers. Read the original owner discussion.

Glenn63 (BMW M140i)

This owner described a firmer ride over small imperfections at low speed, but a substantial improvement over the factory suspension once driving more quickly. A useful reminder that better body control and greater low-speed firmness can coexist. Read the original owner discussion.

M140i owner on Reddit (April 2026)

An owner reported a major improvement in how the car held the road after adding B14 coilovers and rear subframe inserts. They also highlighted the difference made by good Michelin tyres and a fast-road alignment. It is evidence for a well-planned chassis package, not a standalone coilover test. Read the original owner discussion.

ST XA: owner experiences

Verheizer (BMW M140i, F21)

This German BMW forum owner was pleasantly surprised by the comfort compared with the original suspension and reported a calmer rear end, more feedback and improved traction. They also noted an unresolved creaking or knocking sound from the rear-left suspension, with the cause still uncertain. Read the original owner discussion.

newyorker68 (BMW M240i Convertible, F23)

Initially dissatisfied with a low, relatively firm installation, the owner asked for two clicks softer at the front, three clicks softer at the rear and a ride-height increase of around 10mm. They then reported substantially better comfort with good support during brisk driving. Because both height and rebound were adjusted, one change cannot be credited on its own. Read the original owner discussion.

Lard (BMW M140i, F20)

An owner running a low ST XA setup reported no regrets, greater agility through corners and improved high-speed confidence. That is a subjective road-use report, rather than a direct comparison against Bilstein on the same car. Read the original owner discussion.

Bilstein B16: longer-term owner experience

740i (BMW M140i, F20)

After several years with B16 coilovers, this owner said their stiffer springs improved cornering stability. Softer damper settings felt more floaty, while firmer settings cost some comfort. They also reported a front spring breaking during ownership: a useful individual durability report, not proof of a general failure rate. Read the original owner discussion.

What do those reviews actually tell us?

For Bilstein B14, the recurring strength is improved control and a more connected rear end. The recurring compromise is greater firmness over small or sharp bumps, especially at lower speeds. Some owners are perfectly happy using B14s every day; others prefer a more compliant setup.

For ST XA, several owners specifically praise road comfort and chassis composure, while the M240i Convertible account demonstrates the practical value of changing rebound settings and avoiding an unnecessarily low installation. As with any adjustable suspension, the supplied settings may not be ideal for your tyres, roads or preferences.

Neither set of reviews establishes that one brand is universally more comfortable or reliable. Tyres, bump stops, top mounts, bush condition, ride height and geometry all influence the result.

Bilstein B16 vs ST XTA: which is better for track days?

The Bilstein B16 adds a simple 10-position adjustment that changes rebound and compression together. It can be a good choice for an owner who wants to alter damping without having to manage multiple independent circuits.

The ST XTA and XTA Plus 3 move towards more involved chassis setup. Depending on the specified kit, XTA brings performance top mounts and rebound adjustment, while XTA Plus 3 adds separate rebound and low-/high-speed compression control. These features can be valuable on a car using performance tyres and more aggressive geometry, but more adjustment is only useful if it is set correctly.

If you mainly drive on the road with one or two track days per year, a well-set-up B14 or XA may provide all the performance you need. For more frequent circuit work, discuss the complete build — including tyres, camber, spring rates and alignment — before choosing an advanced kit.

Explore ST XTA Plus 3 for BMW F20/F21 and F22/F23 models.

Which coilovers are best for UK roads?

British roads can transition rapidly from smooth tarmac to potholes, cambers and ridges. Lowering alone will not improve how a car deals with these surfaces; sufficient suspension travel and good damping control matter far more.

  • Daily-driven M140i or M240i: ST XA is our pick if you value being able to refine rebound damping to your comfort preference.
  • Simple fast-road M140i: Bilstein B14 is an excellent alternative if you want a well-matched fixed-damping package.
  • Adjustable fast-road car: Bilstein B16 makes sense where straightforward damping changes are important.
  • More dedicated track build: Consider ST XTA or XTA Plus 3 as part of a complete geometry and tyre plan.

These are use-case recommendations, not claims that one kit has won an instrumented road test against another.

Fitment, EDC and suspension geometry: what to check before ordering

BMW M140i models use the F20 five-door or F21 three-door body; M240i models use the F22 Coupé or F23 Convertible. Before ordering, confirm the exact manufacturer's application, drivetrain, axle loads and factory suspension options.

  • RWD or xDrive: some kits are drivetrain-specific.
  • Adaptive M Suspension / EDC: fitting passive coilovers may require approved cancellation hardware or appropriate coding; it does not retain the original electronic damping adjustment.
  • Ride height: stay within the manufacturer's permitted adjustment range and preserve sensible suspension travel.
  • Tyres and wheel clearance: check the chosen wheel/tyre combination at the intended ride height.
  • Alignment: obtain a proper geometry check after fitting and any substantial ride-height change.

For a more involved road/track setup, Suspension Secrets adjustable camber and caster plates for the F20 M140i are one option to investigate, subject to the dampers and mounting hardware used.

Frequently asked questions

Are Bilstein B14 coilovers too stiff for an M140i?

Not necessarily. Owner feedback is mixed: some like their everyday ride, while others describe more firmness over slower, smaller bumps. Ride height, tyres and top-mount choice matter.

Is ST XA better than Bilstein B14?

ST XA has adjustable rebound damping and B14 does not. That makes XA more flexible, but does not make it automatically better for everyone. B14 remains appealing if you prefer a straightforward setup.

Are ST coilovers made by KW?

ST is part of KW Automotive, but ST and KW are separate product ranges with different materials and specifications. They should not be described as identical kits.

Will coilovers improve traction on an M240i?

They can improve suspension control and consistency, but tyre condition, alignment, bush condition, road surface and driving inputs remain critical. An upgraded differential can also affect traction, but it is a separate modification.

Are coilovers worth it if I already have Bilstein B8 dampers and Eibach springs?

Coilovers add ride-height adjustment and, depending on the model, damping adjustment. If the current setup already suits you, an upgrade may be less dramatic than moving from worn factory suspension. Consider the actual problem you want to solve first.

Our verdict: Bilstein or ST for the M140i/M240i?

For a daily-driven BMW M140i or M240i, our preference is ST XA when comfort fine-tuning is important. Genuine owner feedback suggests it can deliver a useful blend of composure and everyday usability when properly installed and adjusted.

For a simpler, more focused fast-road package, Bilstein B14 remains a strong choice. Owner reports consistently describe improved body control, even where the ride becomes firmer.

The most important purchase decision is not the badge on the strut: it is matching the suspension to your intended use and then giving the car a careful installation, appropriate ride height and geometry setup.

Shop BMW suspension at Nineteen72 Performance

We supply performance suspension and chassis components for the BMW M140i, M240i and other M Performance models. Browse the options below or contact us with your exact vehicle specification for fitment advice.

Editorial note: This guide draws on manufacturer specifications and publicly available owner accounts. Owner comments are paraphrased and linked for context. Reported experiences are not a substitute for independently measured performance, and individual complaints do not establish a failure rate.

Reading next

Cobra Sport Volkswagen Golf R Mk7.5 valved resonated cat-back exhaust system
ST XTA plus 3 coilover kit showing front struts with top mounts and separate rear springs and dampers